Reviewers are encouraged to verify that:

• The manuscript aligns with their area of expertise.
• They can dedicate sufficient time to conduct a comprehensive and constructive review.

When serving as a peer reviewer, it is important to adhere to the following constructive guidelines:

• Only agree to review manuscripts in your expertise and strive to provide timely assessments.
• Respect confidentiality throughout the review process and refrain from disclosing any details of the manuscript.
• Refrain from using any information obtained during the peer-review process for personal gain or to discredit others.
• Disclose any potential conflicting interests and seek advice if uncertain.
• Provide objective and constructive feedback, avoiding influence based on the manuscript's origins or the authors' characteristics.
• Offer feedback professionally and encouragingly, avoiding hostile or derogatory comments.

When preparing the report, it's essential to ensure the following:

• The report should provide constructive, accurate, objective, and unambiguous feedback, supported by facts and constructive arguments regarding the manuscript's content.
• Reviewers should use respectful and professional language.
• Focus on necessary corrections and clear suggestions for improvements.

Consider the following aspects constructively during the review process:

• Originality: Look for fresh and innovative ideas in the manuscript.
• Contribution to the field: Evaluate the manuscript's enrichment of existing knowledge and addressing of research gaps.
• Technical quality: Assess methodological rigor and data accuracy.
• Clarity of presentation: Ensure the manuscript's organization and coherence.
• Depth of research: Evaluate the study's thoroughness and support of conclusions.

Reviewers' recommendations should fall into one of the following categories:

• Accept: The manuscript is suitable for publication.
• Minor Corrections: Minor adjustments are needed before publication.
• Major Revision: Significant changes are required for reconsideration.
• Reject: The manuscript is not suitable for publication in its current form.